SFA RELEASE VAR AUDIO AND EXACT REASON WHY AUSTON TRUSTY WAS AWARDED A RED CARD AND IT SPEAKS VOLUME

Views: 220

In what might go down as the most controversial refereeing moment of the Scottish Premiership season, the Scottish Football Association (SFA) has finally released the full VAR audio explaining the decision to send off Celtic defender Auston Trusty in the tense 2–2 draw with Heart of Midlothian FC at Tynecastle Park. And the details? Absolutely explosive. 

This wasn’t just any red card — this was a match-altering decision that swung momentum, sparked furious online backlash, and now, following the VAR audio release, has turned into a full-blown footballing saga that will be debated for years. Here’s how it actually went down behind closed doors. 

🟥 WHAT HAPPENED IN THE GAME — THE MOMENT THAT SHOOK SCOTTISH FOOTBALL

It was the 77th minute at Tynecastle. Celtic were pushing for a win, Hearts were pressing for a lifeline — and then disaster struck. Auston Trusty, Celtic’s rock at the heart of defence, went in with a challenge on Hearts forward Pierre-Landry Kabore.

On the field, referee Steven McLean initially judged the foul to be a yellow card offence — barely even signifying a send-off worthy moment. He didn’t think Kabore had clear control of the ball and wanted to keep the game flowing. 

But that’s when VAR intervened.

📡 THE VAR INTERVENTION — WHAT THE AUDIO REVEALS

Once the incident was flagged to VAR, the tone dramatically changed.

The full audio — released by the Scottish FA — captures every breathtaking moment as VAR officials sift through frame-by-frame analysis. VAR referee John Beaton, speaking to on-field ref McLean, zeroed in on a brutal examination of the play:

“The ball’s on the ground… he’s going to gain possession… there’s no defender that can get back to stop him…” — this is VAR reality. 

That’s right — VAR officials believed that, at the point of Trusty’s challenge, Kabore would have taken control of the ball in a central position, with no defender capable of intervening, and a clear path to goal staring him in the face. That fits the textbook definition of DOGSO — Denying an Obvious Goal-Scoring Opportunity. 

And just like that — in the blink of an eye — McLean changed his mind, upgrading the decision from a yellow to a straight red card.

📢 WHAT THE VAR AUDIO 

ACTUALLY

 SAID

Here are the explosive snippets from the released audio that football fans can’t stop talking about:

📍 McLean on initial call:

“On-field decision is yellow card… I didn’t think he had control of the ball.” 

📍 VAR Beaton stepping in:

“OK Stevie, we’re checking on-field decision… Tell me what you see here?” 

📍 VAR Nicolson asserting control:

“…I think he’s going to gain possession of the ball.” 

📍 Beaton’s verdict:

“…there’s a reasonable expectation that the attacker’s going to take possession… no defender can stop him…” 

📍 McLean deciding:

“He would be in control of the ball… opportunity to score a goal. Okay, red card.” 

Those moments — now public — have left the entirety of Scottish football questioning EVERYTHING about VAR’s role, influence, and sanity. 

🔥 THE FALLOUT — CELTIC FURIOUS, APPEAL REJECTED

Following the match, Celtic were furious, immediately appealing the red card because they believed the original yellow should have stayed.

Their argument was simple:

• Kabore didn’t have full control of the ball
• Another defender (like Dane Murray) was in a covering position
• And even if a foul occurred, it wasn’t a Dogso scenario.  

Despite their furious statements and media pressure, the appeal was dismissed by the SFA — meaning Trusty’s red card would stand, and he would miss Celtic’s next league match. 

That refusal to overturn has only deepened the outrage.

🧠 WILLIE COLLUM WEIGHS IN

Adding fuel to the fire, Willie Collum — head of referees at the Scottish FA — publicly defended the decision.

Collum argued that:

• VAR correctly identified DOGSO
• Trusty’s position and Kabore’s control met the threshold
• The covering defender was too far to affect the play

…and ultimately that the red card was, in Collum’s view, the correct call under the Laws of the Game. 

This has only added insult to injury for Celtic fans — with many interpreting Collum’s backing as blind faith in technology over common sense. 

🤯 SOCIAL MEDIA ERUPTS — FANS ARE FUMING

Once the VAR audio was leaked, fans erupted across forums, social media threads, and Reddit threads:

• “Never a red!”
• “Trusty is never Trusty again!”
• “Two defenders were back, VAR lies!”
• “This is why VAR ruins football!”  

Some even accused the SFA of having hidden agendas or being biased — the kind of conspiracy-fuelled reactions only moments like this can ignite. 

⚖️ WHAT THIS MEANS FOR FOOTBALL — THE BROADER IMPLICATIONS

This Trusty red card incident isn’t just about one player or one match. It has opened a Pandora’s box of issues:

📌 TRANSPARENCY WITH VAR

The VAR audio release itself is rare — and now fans want more of them every week. 

📌 QUESTIONS ABOUT CONSISTENCY

If VAR upgraded Trusty’s card with these criteria — what about every similar challenge? Fans are crying inconsistency in officiating rulings. 

📌 CULTURAL FRICTION

Scout pundits are arguing that VAR’s involvement dilutes referee authority and removes human context from decisions. 

⚽ FINAL THOUGHT: DID SCOTTISH FOOTBALL JUST LOSE THE PLOT?

Whether you stand with the referees, or you’re screaming bloody murder from the terraces — one thing is certain:

The release of the VAR audio has let football fans peek behind the curtain — and what they saw has shaken the Scottish game to its core. 

For Celtic, it’s another bitter twist in a title race that hinges on margins smaller than a narrow decision. For Hearts, they walked away with a precious point. But for the world of football lovers everywhere?

This might be the moment VAR crossed a line — where technology didn’t just decide a red card — it sparked a revolution. 🔥