BBC pundits reveals why spfa crowned Celtic best team in Scotland this season ahead of rangers despite worst performance this season

The discussion surrounding Celtic’s status as the best team in Scotland this season, despite claims that their performances were weaker than in previous years, highlights the complex nature of evaluating success in football. BBC pundits, along with other analysts, have repeatedly pointed out that Celtic’s superiority is not solely defined by match-to-match brilliance but by broader factors such as consistency, resilience, league context, and overall dominance across the season.

A key argument made by pundits is the importance of consistency. Celtic may not have been at their sparkling best in every match, but over the course of the league campaign, they demonstrated reliability in accumulating points. Football titles are not awarded based on a handful of standout games; they are earned across months of steady results. Even in fixtures where Celtic underperformed or failed to impress, they avoided prolonged slumps and always managed to regain momentum. This ability to remain stable when form dipped contributed heavily to their championship success.

Another theme highlighted by commentators is the relative underperformance of their rivals, particularly Rangers. Although Rangers produced certain impressive displays  including heavy victories that drew praise from pundits  they often failed to sustain that level over time. As a result, while Celtic occasionally looked vulnerable, Rangers lacked the consistency required to take advantage. This contrast between Celtic’s steadiness and Rangers’ sporadic form made the final league outcome less surprising to analysts. The title was not simply won by Celtic playing well; it was also shaped by Rangers failing to maintain pressure over the full season.

Squad depth and managerial strategy also played crucial roles. Under Brendan Rodgers, Celtic benefited from strong squad rotation, tactical adjustments, and the ability to recover quickly from setbacks. Even when performances generated criticism  for example, over a lack of intensity or complacency  the team demonstrated resilience. Their ability to respond after poor results, rather than collapse under pressure, impressed pundits who value psychological strength as much as technical quality.

Additionally, some pundits pointed to structural factors that contribute to Celtic’s continued superiority. Over the years, Celtic have built a powerful system: strong financial backing, better facilities, significant experience in title races, and a winning culture. These elements create a built-in advantage that many other clubs in Scotland find difficult to match. As a result, even a “weaker” Celtic season is often still strong enough to outperform the rest of the league.

Finally, the timing of Celtic’s best performances mattered. When the pressure intensified in the closing stages of the season, Celtic showed their champion mentality with decisive victories. Their ability to deliver dominant, high-quality performances exactly when required reinforced the idea that they remained the strongest and most reliable force in the league.