Official VAR Statement Regarding the Manchester United vs. Brighton Penalty Decision
Date: January 19, 2025
In light of the events that transpired during the English Premier League match between Manchester United and Brighton, we wish to clarify the rationale behind the penalty awarded in the 19th minute of the game. The decision has sparked considerable debate among fans and analysts alike, and it is essential to provide transparency regarding the VAR process and the criteria that guided our decision-making.
During the first half of the match, a pivotal moment occurred when Brighton defender Carlos Belaba was involved in a challenge against Manchester United striker Joshua ZIRKZEE inside the penalty area. As the play unfolded, ZIRKZEE was under pressure from Belaba, who attempted to regain possession of the ball. However, in his effort to challenge for the ball, Belaba made contact with ZIRKZEE, resulting in a foul being called by the on-field referee.
Upon reviewing the incident through VAR, our team assessed several key factors. The primary focus was on whether the contact made by Belaba constituted a foul under the Laws of the Game. The VAR officials closely examined multiple camera angles and replays to evaluate the nature of the challenge. It was determined that Belaba’s actions met the criteria for a foul, as he impeded ZIRKZEE’s ability to play the ball in a manner deemed reckless.
The VAR protocol dictates that any clear and obvious error made by the on-field referee can be overturned. In this case, after thorough examination, it was concluded that the referee’s initial decision to award a penalty was justified. The decision was communicated to the on-field referee, who subsequently pointed to the penalty spot, allowing Manchester United the opportunity to convert the penalty.
Following the award of the penalty, Manchester United captain Bruno Fernandes stepped up to take the kick. With precision and composure, Fernandes successfully converted the penalty, bringing the score to 1-1. This goal not only equalized the match but also underscored the significance of the VAR intervention in influencing the game’s outcome.
We acknowledge the concerns raised by Brighton fans regarding the penalty decision. Football is an emotional sport, and decisions made on the pitch can evoke strong reactions. However, it is crucial to emphasize that the VAR system is designed to enhance fairness and accuracy in officiating. Our commitment is to ensure that every decision is made with the utmost integrity and in accordance with the established guidelines.
As a governing body, we continually strive to improve the implementation of VAR, taking into account feedback from players, clubs, and supporters. The intention is to foster a clearer understanding of the VAR process and to enhance the overall experience for everyone involved in the game.
In conclusion, the penalty awarded to Manchester United in the 19th minute of the match against Brighton was a result of a thorough VAR review process. The decision was made based on the clear evidence of a foul committed by Carlos Belaba against Joshua ZIRKZEE. We appreciate the passion of all fans and encourage ongoing dialogue about the role of technology in football. Our aim is to uphold the integrity of the game while ensuring that the rules are applied consistently and fairly.
Thank you for your understanding and support.
Leave a Reply