We Simulated Gareth Southgate’s First Season as Tottenham Manager—The Results Are Absolutely Shocking
With Gareth Southgate rumored to transition into Premier League management after his stint as England’s head coach, many are curious about how he would fare in club football. To explore this possibility, we simulated Southgate’s first season as Tottenham Hotspur manager using advanced football simulation software. The results were filled with unexpected highs, lows, and plenty of surprises.
Southgate’s Appointment and Philosophy
Gareth Southgate was hired to replace Ange Postecoglou after the 2024/25 season, stepping into a Tottenham team hungry for success and stability. Known for his pragmatic and structured style, Southgate’s focus was on defensive solidity and teamwork—a stark contrast to Tottenham’s traditionally attacking philosophy. Fans were cautiously optimistic, hoping he could bring stability and end their long trophy drought.
Summer Transfer Window
Southgate immediately sought to reshape the squad to fit his disciplined style. However, the transfer market presented challenges as some players Tottenham had targeted were unavailable due to recent moves:
•James Ward-Prowse remained at Nottingham Forest, where he had made an impressive start after joining from West Ham.
•Ivan Toney was unavailable, having recently joined Al-Ahli in Saudi Arabia.
Instead, Southgate made alternative signings to strengthen the squad:
•Kalvin Phillips from Manchester City to provide defensive stability in midfield.
•Marc Guéhi from Crystal Palace, adding youth and quality to the defense.
•Ollie Watkins from Aston Villa to bolster the attack in place of Harry Kane.
Premier League Performance
Tottenham’s league campaign under Southgate was a mixed bag. The team began strongly, showing defensive organization and a newfound resilience. However, a lack of creativity in the final third became a recurring issue as the season progressed.
Key Results:
•A thrilling 3-2 victory over Arsenal in the North London Derby showed Southgate’s ability to rally his team in big games.
•A frustrating 0-0 draw against relegation-threatened Sheffield United highlighted the team’s struggles against deep-lying defenses.
•A heavy 4-1 defeat to Liverpool at Anfield exposed weaknesses against elite opposition.
Tottenham ultimately finished 6th in the Premier League, earning a Europa League spot but falling short of Champions League qualification—a result that left fans divided.
Cup Competitions: Mixed Fortunes
Southgate’s focus on silverware saw mixed results:
•Carabao Cup: Spurs reached the semi-finals but were eliminated by Manchester City, who won 3-1 on aggregate.
•FA Cup: A surprising exit in the fifth round to Nottingham Forest, where James Ward-Prowse scored a stunning free-kick to knock his former suitors out of the competition.
Key Player Performances
Several players adapted well to Southgate’s system, while others struggled:
•Son Heung-min: Thrived as captain, contributing 20 goals and 8 assists across all competitions.
•Ollie Watkins: Scored 16 league goals but struggled in high-pressure matches against top-six opponents.
•Dejan Kulusevski: Found new life as a versatile attacking option, registering 10 goals and 12 assists.
•Kalvin Phillips: Provided stability in midfield but was criticized for his lack of creativity in build-up play.
Fan and Media Reactions
The reaction to Southgate’s first season was mixed:
•Positive: Many fans appreciated the improved defensive organization and big-game performances, particularly the derby win against Arsenal.
•Negative: Critics pointed to the lack of attacking flair, with one fan commenting, “Southgate’s system is too cautious for a club like Spurs.”
Pundits debated whether Southgate’s conservative approach was suited to the fast-paced, high-scoring nature of the Premier League.
Southgate’s Post-Season Reflections
In a press conference after the season, Southgate expressed optimism despite the challenges:
“It’s been a transitional year, but the players have shown great character. We’ve built a solid foundation, and I’m confident we can push for greater success next season.”
Conclusion: A Divisive First Season
Gareth Southgate’s simulated first season as Tottenham manager revealed both his strengths and limitations. While he brought discipline and defensive resilience, his conservative tactics often stifled the team’s creativity. Finishing 6th in the league and falling short in the cups left fans with mixed feelings.
Would Gareth Southgate truly thrive in club football, or is his skillset better suited to international management? Only time—and perhaps a real-world opportunity—will provide the answer.
Leave a Reply