This summer’s transfer window took a dramatic turn after a promising deal seemed all but sealed. A player central to ambitious plans for the upcoming season has now become the focus of intense speculation, as his parent club remains firm on retaining him despite mounting external pressures from elite suitors.
Growing Doubts Over Strategic Celtic Coup
John Anderson, former Newcastle defender, delivered a blunt appraisal: no club can realistically afford Alexander Isak. His assertion came after videos of the Sweden striker missing Celtic’s pre-season friendly spread across social media, rekindling debate about his future at St James’ Park. Anderson’s perspective has since been echoed by fans and analysts alike, questioning whether any interested party can match Newcastle’s valuation or even persuade the player to leave.
Why Alexander Isak Became Celtic’s Dream Target
With his fleet-footed athleticism, aerial dominance, and ability to score consistently under pressure, many believed he was the missing piece to Celtic’s attack. His absence in a key friendly was seen as indicative of Newcastle’s commitment to holding firm, potentially signaling that Isak is not for sale especially if no club can guarantee a world-record fee.
When Liverpool emerged as a reported suitor with a staggering £120 million offer, it appeared to fall well short of Newcastle’s rumored £150 million valuation. The gap between interest and possibility seems wider than expected, and the transfer is increasingly looking like a publicity gambit rather than a genuine possibility.
Isak’s Impact at Newcastle & Market Value
Since joining Newcastle in 2022 from Real Sociedad, Alexander Isak has flourished, becoming one of the most lethal strikers in the Premier League. In the 2024–25 season alone, he scored an impressive 27 league goals and added six assists. His 44 goals in 86 league games make him a standout performer and a cornerstone figure at St James’ Park.
At just 25, with a contract through 2028, he carries both longevity and proven track record which are rare commodities in today’s transfer market. It’s why insiders firmly believe that only a mega-offer, or stronger Champions League credentials from suitors, could tempt Newcastle into a sale.
Anderson Speaks: “You Can’t Afford Him”
Alexander Isak’s name featured heavily in the body of this transfer narrative after John Anderson’s frank declaration: “Nobody can afford to buy him.” His words underline the gulf between speculative interest and actual financial feasibility. Liverpool, Al Hilal, or any potential buyer would have to surpass seller expectations financially and sportingly to shift Newcastle’s stance. And so far, none have delivered.
Liverpool’s £120M Offer: A Bargain?
Despite offering to make Alexander Isak the club’s marquee signing, Liverpool reportedly proposed *£120 million*, a figure instantly dismissed as insufficient. Newcastle’s public rejection made it clear: no matter the prestige attached to the buying club, the valuation remains untouchable.
While Liverpool has shifted focus toward Hugo Ekitike, a French forward Newcastle themselves targeted, their failure to align with Newcastle’s demands has effectively eliminated them from serious contention for Isak.
Celtic’s Transfer Blow: Dreams Against Reality
Celtic’s pursuit of Isak never reached public clarity in terms of financial offer, but club insiders suggested that negotiations had progressed to an advanced stage. Fans were optimistic after months of reported discussions, only to be dealt a harsh corporate reality: Newcastle’s valuation exceeds global market norms.
The failure to land Isak has left Celtic in a difficult position. Plans to build the attacking core around him must now pivot. The absence of a marquee striker signing could impact the squad’s competitiveness and ability to challenge on multiple fronts.
The Broader Landscape: Who Could Afford Isak?
Even top clubs outside the UK face limitations. Serie A and Ligue 1 sufficiently lack the financial clout to outbid or outmatch Newcastle’s expectations. Meanwhile, Saudi clubs like Al Hilal have shown serious interest and financial might, but still fall short on terms that satisfy Newcastle’s valuation or Isak’s European ambitions.
There is also speculation about the player’s preferences. Isak is reported to be seeking long‑term Champions League football and not a short-term payday abroad. Newcastle, still on the ascent in European status, may also play a supporting role in retaining him through new contract negotiations.
Conclusion
John Anderson’s words ring true: “Nobody can afford to buy him.” With his agent signalling openness to options yet no concrete bid materializing, Alexander Isak’s future appears to remain at Newcastle at least until someone eclipses £150 million or guarantees long-term European status.
For Celtic, the dream of securing their lead striker has shattered, leaving them to regroup. For Isak, another season at Tyneside remains likely. For fans of the beautiful game, it’s a reminder that not all transfer rumors amount to reality especially when figures this astronomical are involved.
