In a recent and heated exchange that has set the Scottish football community abuzz, former Rangers striker Kris Boyd boldly asserted that “Rangers FC will always be the biggest club in the Premiership. That will never change.” This proclamation did not sit well with former Celtic forward and outspoken pundit Chris Sutton, who launched into a passionate rebuttal, dismissing Boyd’s comments as “absolute drivel” and a blatant violation of factual accuracy.
The Origins of the Debate
The longstanding rivalry between Rangers and Celtic is one of the most intense in football history, with both clubs boasting rich traditions, passionate fanbases, and a plethora of domestic and international accolades. Boyd’s recent statement reignited discussions about which club holds the mantle of being the “biggest” in Scottish football.
Kris Boyd’s Perspective
Kris Boyd, known for his prolific goal-scoring record with Rangers, emphasized the club’s extensive fanbase, historical success, and cultural significance as the foundation for his claim. He argued that despite Celtic’s recent domestic achievements, Rangers’ overall legacy and global reach cement their status as the premier club in Scotland.
Chris Sutton’s Counterargument
Chris Sutton, never one to shy away from controversy, responded emphatically during a live broadcast. He labeled Boyd’s remarks as “nonsensical” and highlighted Celtic’s recent dominance in the Scottish Premiership, including multiple league titles and domestic trebles, as evidence of their current superiority. Sutton also pointed to Celtic’s consistent participation and performances in European competitions as a testament to their stature.
Statistical Comparison
To provide context to this debate, a comparison of both clubs’ achievements is essential:
- Domestic League Titles: As of the 2024/2025 season, Rangers have secured 55 Scottish Premiership titles, while Celtic have claimed 53.
- Scottish Cups: Celtic lead with 40 Scottish Cup victories compared to Rangers’ 34.
- European Success: Both clubs have tasted European glory; Celtic famously won the European Cup in 1967, becoming the first British club to do so, while Rangers secured the Cup Winners’ Cup in 1972.
Beyond silverware, factors such as fanbase size, stadium capacity, and financial performance contribute to a club’s overall stature.
- Stadium Capacity: Celtic Park holds approximately 60,411 spectators, slightly edging out Rangers’ Ibrox Stadium, which accommodates around 50,817.
- Average Attendance: Both clubs consistently report high average attendances, often ranking among the top in Europe relative to their city populations.
- Financial Performance: In recent years, both clubs have reported robust financial health, with revenues bolstered by merchandise sales, broadcasting deals, and European competition participation.
The global reach of both clubs is undeniable. Supporters’ clubs are established worldwide, and their matches draw international viewership. The “Old Firm” derby between Rangers and Celtic is renowned globally for its intensity and historical significance.
Media and Pundit Reactions
The Boyd-Sutton exchange has elicited reactions from various media outlets and football analysts. Some view the debate as a reflection of the passionate rivalry that defines Scottish football, while others see it as a media-fueled controversy lacking substantive merit.
Unsurprisingly, fans are divided along club lines. Rangers supporters echo Boyd’s sentiments, emphasizing their club’s resilience and historical achievements. Conversely, Celtic fans align with Sutton, pointing to recent successes and the club’s progressive trajectory.
The question of which club is the “biggest” in Scottish football is inherently subjective, influenced by metrics chosen and personal allegiances. While Rangers boast a rich history and significant achievements, Celtic’s recent dominance and consistent performances cannot be overlooked. Ultimately, the vibrant debate underscores the passion and intensity that make the Rangers-Celtic rivalry one of the most compelling in world football.
