Celtic fans are up in arms after fresh footage has emerged highlighting a costly error from Cameron Carter-Vickers in their defeat to Rangers. The defender has come under intense scrutiny following the Old Firm clash, with many supporters now calling for manager Brendan Rodgers to offload him—either on loan or permanently.
The incident in question took place at a crucial moment in the game when Celtic were holding on in a tightly contested battle against their arch-rivals. Footage shows Carter-Vickers failing to deal with a dangerous attack, ultimately leading to a decisive Rangers goal. The mistake has sparked outrage among the fanbase, who believe the defender’s lapse in concentration proved to be the turning point in the match.
The American centre-back, usually a reliable presence in Celtic’s backline, has been a key figure for the club since his arrival. However, this latest performance has raised serious concerns, with some questioning whether he should continue as a first-choice defender.
Following the match, social media was flooded with reactions from frustrated Celtic supporters. Many believe that Carter-Vickers’ mistake was unacceptable, and some have gone as far as demanding he be dropped from the squad or even moved on in the upcoming transfer window.
One fan wrote:
“This is not the first time Carter-Vickers has cost us in a big game. If he’s not up for it, we need to move him on—loan or permanent, I don’t care!”
Another added:
“Brendan Rodgers needs to make a statement. Players who make these mistakes in crucial games should not be automatic starters.”
The anger among the Celtic faithful is understandable, given the importance of the Old Firm derby. A win could have given them a major boost in the title race, but instead, the defeat has left them vulnerable, with Rangers gaining momentum.
Brendan Rodgers has not publicly addressed the criticism of Carter-Vickers, but with the defender now under heavy scrutiny, the manager will need to make a big decision ahead of Celtic’s upcoming fixtures. Dropping a player of Carter-Vickers’ stature would be a major call, but Rodgers has shown in the past that he is not afraid to make tough choices when necessary.
Despite the backlash, Carter-Vickers still has strong support within the club. Many believe he has been one of Celtic’s most consistent performers over the past two seasons, and this error should not define his time at the club. Some fans argue that blaming him alone for the defeat is unfair, as Celtic’s performance as a whole was not up to standard.
With the title race still open, Celtic cannot afford to dwell on the loss. However, the pressure is now on Rodgers to address the concerns of the fans and ensure that such costly mistakes do not happen again.
Carter-Vickers, meanwhile, will have to respond on the pitch. If he remains in the starting lineup, he must prove that he can handle the pressure of big games and bounce back from his error. If Rodgers decides to drop him, it could be a sign that his place in the squad is no longer secure.
The coming weeks will be crucial in determining Carter-Vickers’ future at Celtic. While some fans are calling for his exit, others believe he deserves a chance to redeem himself. Either way, the fallout from his mistake against Rangers is unlikely to die down anytime soon.
