In a thrilling Old Firm derby at Celtic Park on March 16, 2025, Rangers secured a dramatic 3-2 victory over Celtic, marking a significant milestone for interim manager Barry Ferguson, who became the first Rangers manager since Walter Smith in 1991 to win his debut derby.
Match Overview
The match began with high intensity, as both teams sought to assert dominance. Rangers struck first in the 12th minute when Nicolas Raskin headed home from a corner, capitalizing on a lapse in Celtic’s defense. The visitors doubled their lead in the 35th minute through Abdallah Sima, who showcased individual brilliance with a solo run culminating in a precise finish.
Facing a two-goal deficit, Celtic responded with resilience in the second half. Daizen Maeda reignited hope for the home side by scoring a header early in the half. The momentum continued in Celtic’s favor as Reo Hatate displayed composure to equalize, bringing the score to 2-2.
However, Rangers had the final say. In the 88th minute, substitute Hamza Igamane delivered a decisive blow, finding the back of the net to secure the victory for the visitors.
Controversial Officiating Decisions
The match was not without controversy, particularly concerning the officiating by referee Steven McLean:
1. Disallowed Goal: In the 75th minute, Celtic’s Daizen Maeda appeared to have scored a goal that would have given Celtic the lead. However, after a VAR review, the goal was disallowed due to an alleged offside in the buildup. The decision was met with frustration from Celtic players and supporters, who felt the call was marginal.
2. Penalty Appeal: Later in the match, Celtic winger Jota was brought down in the Rangers penalty box. Despite appeals from the Celtic side, referee McLean waved play on, denying what many perceived to be a clear penalty. This decision has been widely debated, with discussions focusing on the consistency of officiating in critical match situations.
SPFL’s Response
In light of the controversies, the Scottish Professional Football League (SPFL) released a statement acknowledging the concerns raised:
“The Scottish Professional Football League is aware of the discussions surrounding the officiating of the recent fixture between Celtic and Rangers. We take all matters regarding refereeing standards seriously and can confirm that a formal review of the match will be conducted. Refereeing integrity is of utmost importance to the league, and we remain committed to ensuring the highest standards in officiating.”
Celtic’s Position
Celtic Football Club has expressed dissatisfaction with the officiating during the match. Manager Brendan Rodgers revealed that referee Steven McLean informed him post-match that the disallowed goal was a result of a VAR decision, stating the player was “marginally offside.” Rodgers challenged this explanation, citing a lack of clear evidence to support the decision.
Fan and Media Reaction
The match has ignited widespread debate:
• Supporters’ Outrage: Celtic fans have taken to social media and forums to express their frustration, calling for greater accountability and transparency in refereeing decisions.
• Media Analysis: Various media outlets have scrutinized the officiating, emphasizing the need for consistent and fair standards in the league.
Looking Ahead
The SPFL’s investigation into Steven McLean’s officiating is ongoing. The outcome may lead to discussions about implementing measures to enhance the quality and consistency of refereeing in Scottish football. As the investigation unfolds, stakeholders across the sport will be keenly observing the developments, hoping for resolutions that uphold the integrity of the game.
