In a recent Scottish Premiership match between Kilmarnock and Celtic, a controversial goal by Kilmarnock has ignited debates among fans and officials. The Scottish Football Association (SFA) has now released the VAR audio from the incident, shedding light on the decision-making process and the rationale behind not drawing the offside line during the review.
The Controversial Goal
The incident occurred when Kilmarnock’s forward appeared to be in an offside position before receiving the ball and scoring. Celtic players and supporters immediately protested, urging the referee to consult the Video Assistant Referee (VAR) system. Despite the apparent offside, the goal was allowed to stand, leading to widespread confusion and calls for transparency.
VAR Audio Release
Responding to the outcry, the SFA released the VAR audio to provide insight into the officials’ deliberations. The audio reveals a discussion between on-field referee Don Robertson and VAR official Greg Aitken. In the conversation, Aitken quickly assesses the situation, stating, “I think he’s just made himself big and not moved,” referring to the Kilmarnock player. This assessment led to the decision that no offside line needed to be drawn, and the goal was validated without further review. 
Reasoning Behind Not Drawing the Offside Line
The decision not to draw the offside line was based on Aitken’s interpretation that the Kilmarnock player did not actively move into an offside position and that his actions did not interfere with play. This judgment aligns with the current offside rules, which consider a player’s movement and involvement in active play. However, the swift conclusion and lack of a detailed review have been criticized for potentially overlooking critical aspects of the play.
Reactions and Implications
The release of the VAR audio has elicited mixed reactions. Some commend the SFA’s effort toward transparency, while others argue that the audio exposes flaws in the VAR process, particularly concerning the haste of the decision and the failure to utilize all available technology, such as the offside line. This incident has prompted discussions about the consistency and accuracy of VAR decisions in Scottish football.
In response to the controversy, SFA’s Head of Referees, Willie Collum, acknowledged the mistake in the VAR Review Show, admitting that the officials got it wrong.  This admission has intensified calls for improved training and protocols to ensure that such errors are minimized in the future.
Conclusion
The release of the VAR audio in the Kilmarnock vs. Celtic match offers a rare glimpse into the decision-making process of match officials. While transparency is a positive step, the incident underscores the need for meticulous application of VAR technology and consistent adherence to review protocols to maintain the integrity of the game.
Leave a Reply